Legislatively-Mandated Single Viewpoint on Reading Education

The Ohio State University Chapter of the American Association of University Professors (AAUP-OSU) stands in solidarity with the faculty members in our Teaching and Learning (T&L) department as they navigate the stress of a state-required audit and the associated degradation of their academic freedom. Through ORC Sections 3313.6028 and 3333.048, the Ohio legislature has mandated a single viewpoint in the field of reading education and is enforcing that viewpoint through an exhaustive audit of courses, materials, and instructors’ compliance. The state has authority to mandate curricular changes, but the implementation must also maintain the right to academic freedom. We know how much work T&L faculty have put into complying with an audit that has disregarded their academic freedom. They have sat through countless meetings and interviews. They have changed their syllabi and redacted textbooks and other professional readings to align with a single viewpoint. Many have had to silence their own and others’ decades-long scholarship and understanding of the multiple ways children learn to read. When the state bans opposing viewpoints, it undermines the free exchange of ideas. While research shows the “science of reading” is an important, even core, component of early reading pedagogy, it must be understood in the context of a longer history of reading research, a range of views on approaches that serve diverse needs, and a balanced view of the role of meaning in learning to read. The faculty fully expect and deserve to be deemed aligned and compliant with the state’s mandate. AAUP-OSU will work tirelessly to restore the T&L faculty's academic freedom because it is a prerequisite to students receiving an unabridged education. Our T&L students must receive a complete education today because they will be our children’s teachers tomorrow.
The state of Ohio benefits when future teachers are comprehensively trained on best practices, knowledgeable about the history of the field, and equipped with the widest set of tools available to them – not when they are limited to a state-mandated single viewpoint.



